Summit Denali lacks an African American perspective due to location

By Riley Quigley

Staff Writer

As a classroom at Summit Denali High School talks about race, heads begin to turn to senior Claire Mallinson. She is the only African American student in her classroom.

DSC_0017

Denali senior Claire Mallinson says she’s the only African American student in her classroom. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

 

“Every time a topic like that is brought up everyone turns and looks at you,” Mallinson said. As the sole African American student in the classroom, she is seen as having all the answers. She said, “Everyone expects you to be the next Rosa Parks, but I’m still trying to figure this out too.”

To figure out why Denali has such a small African American population, first take a look at the school’s location. Summit Denali is located in the city of Sunnyvale, California. 

Screenshot 2020-01-15 at 11.49.41 AM

According to the 2010 United States Census, Sunnyvale is primarily White and Asian. GRAPHIC CREDIT: United States Census Bureau

According to the 2010 United States Census, Sunnyvale was 45.9% Asian, 42.1% White, 17.3% Latino and 1.7% African American. 

Screenshot 2020-01-15 at 11.49.59 AM

According to the 2018 United States Census, the United States as a whole is 13.4% African American. GRAPHIC CREDIT: United States Census Bureau

The United States as a whole, as of 2018, was 76.5% White, 5.9% Asian, 13.4% African American and 18.3% Latino. 

Screenshot 2020-01-15 at 11.47.56 AM

Summit Denali middle and high school demographics for the 2018-2019 school year show a lack of African American students. GRAPHIC CREDIT: Santa Clara Board of Education

Comparatively, as of the 2018-2019 school year, Summit Denali was 33.6% White, 30.3% Latino, 17.4% Asian and 0.9% African American. This means that, as of 2018, six out of 575 total Summit Denali students were African American.

Those statistics include both the Summit Denali middle school and high school. The administration of Summit Denali high school was unable to get the isolated numbers of the high school by publication deadline. They acknowledge that these collective numbers are a good representation of the high school demographics.

DSC_0019

Denali Operations Manager Amrit Chima says it’s challenging to maintain strong diversity in the Bay Area. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

Denali Operations Manager Amrit Chima offers her insight on the lack of African American students. She said that in the Bay Area, “We’re seeing an outflux of certain types of families and it can be challenging to maintain a strong diversity.” 

When asked about where Summit markets their school, Ms. Chima said, “I think that there are certainly priorities on targeting local communities.” This means that Summit is aiming to directly pull from Sunnyvale, which has a low African American population.

Sven Engvall, who teaches Modern World to freshmen students, said that a lack of diversity can affect students. “I think that it definitely affects learning.” 

DSC_0070

Denali Modern World teacher Sven Engvall thinks a lack of diversity could definitely affect learning. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

“If we have a whole white or Asian classroom, we might only get one perspective,” Mr. Engvall said. “Latino, Black, Native populations, without them it can be very hard to build a culture of empathy in that classroom.”

When asked about teaching sensitive topics regarding race, he said, “If we don’t have the affected people, it feels like we are first world people talking about how to help disadvantaged, oppressed people who we put in that situation. And that’s not necessarily helping if we are just speaking for them.”

Denali freshman Malachi Daniher reported similar experiences to Mallinson. He said, “When I have to talk about race, everyone is like, ‘Oh my god, he’s black.’ It makes me feel weird to learn about it because everyone is looking at me and expecting answers from me.”

DSC_0077

Denali freshman Malachi Daniher says he feels uncomfortable speaking about sensitive topics about race. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

Daniher also said he’s almost always the lone African American in his classroom because at Summit Denali he knows less than five African American people. 

“I like talking and giving my opinion on everything, but when I talk about it I get afraid to talk about it because all the non-colored people can’t relate or talk about it,” Daniher said. “My learning is affected when there’s only one African American to speak about it.” 

Mallinson said that even when the classroom does have productive conversations about race, she isn’t always heard. “Opinions tend to come from a ‘woke’ white person. A lot of the time people say things like we don’t see color but if you don’t see color you don’t see me. They think it’s woke but in reality it’s just negative.” 

Mallinson continued to say that when she does end up talking, she is seen as speaking for all African Americans. “Everyone thinks I speak for all black people — you’re asking my opinion, not the whole races. I don’t speak for everyone.” She said that when there’s only one African American, it’s hard to compare and contrast different African American experiences when it comes to race. 

Mallinson also said that the African American experience at Summit is different than other minorities. “Everyone has their groups, there are enough White, Asian, Latin groups for them to not feel alone.”

DSC_0282-2

Posters for the Summit Denali Muslim Student Association shows that diversity is celebrated at Denali. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

However, Mr. Engvall acknowledged that it’s hard to grow the school’s African American population because of Denali’s status as a growing school. “I think Denali is still a growing campus who accepts any person who applies, if we’re trying to get a more diverse population sometimes that can’t happen.” 

DSC_0257-2

A wall of activism posters at Summit Denali High School tackle almost every issue. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

Mallinson agreed that it’s hard for Summit to have a higher population of African Americans, due to location. She said, “You can’t force diversity.” 

Featured Image (at top of page): Mr. Engvall’s classroom is primarily white, which is not uncommon considering the demographics at Denali. PHOTO CREDIT: Riley Quigley

 

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.